There is something absurd about telling a Family Court judge: You may decide whether a child is safe going home, but you may not ask for a drug test that could help you answer that question.
Under New York City’s new policy, a judge can no longer request an on-site drug test on the judge’s own initiative. A lawyer for the child or the parent has to make the request. The court can still weigh the consequences of sending a child home—but the judge’s ability to gather relevant information has been narrowed.
Privacy and dignity matter. Testing should be handled respectfully, results kept confidential, and requests grounded in the facts of a case. But those safeguards don’t explain why the person responsible for making the decision should be blocked from asking a reasonable question.
A drug test is not a verdict. It does not, by itself, prove someone is an unfit parent. It is one piece of information that may help a judge understand whether a child can safely be placed in a parent’s care. A clean test might even help a parent show progress and move closer to reunification.
Family Court exists to decide what is in a child’s best interests. That requires gathering facts, weighing evidence and making hard judgments. Turning a judge into a referee who must wait for someone else to request basic information makes little sense. If the test is relevant and there is a sound reason to ask for it, why should the judge have to sit on their hands?
The stakes are not abstract. When a child is vulnerable, a mistaken decision can have devastating consequences. No test can guarantee safety, and no policy can prevent every tragedy. But stripping judges of a reasonable tool does not make the system fairer by itself. It may simply make the court less able to see what is happening.
Parents deserve dignity and due process. Children deserve a court willing and able to investigate the facts. A system that says judges must decide whether a child is safe while limiting their ability to ask relevant questions has lost sight of its most basic responsibility.