A city that respects private ownership does not make the government’s preferred buyers the first guests at the negotiating table. Yet that is the principle behind Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s new Community Opportunity to Purchase Act.
COPA gives qualified nonprofits and community groups the first chance to make offers on certain apartment buildings. If an owner later finds a buyer, one of those groups may get another opportunity to match the offer. The city says qualifying groups receive 145 days to make an initial offer, followed by an additional period to exercise that matching right. The law does not transfer every building to the city, but it does put government-approved buyers in a privileged position in the sale of covered properties.
That is a profound change in the relationship between the city and property owners. An owner may hold the deed, pay the taxes, cover the mortgage, fund repairs and shoulder the risk—but when it is time to sell, the city has inserted its chosen buyers into the process. That is not a routine administrative detail. It is government using its power to reshape a private transaction.
The administration calls COPA a tool to preserve affordable housing. But preserving housing requires more than controlling who gets the first chance to buy it. Buildings need money for heat, plumbing, roofs, insurance, taxes and repairs. Owners need rental income and access to buyers willing and able to invest. Add delay, uncertainty and restrictions to an already expensive business, and some owners may decide that the risks of owning in New York are no longer worth taking.
COPA does not itself bar evictions or erase mortgage payments. Those are separate policies. But landlords already face a pileup of costs and regulations, and the city cannot pretend each new restriction exists in isolation. When government limits an owner’s options while leaving the bills untouched, it shifts more risk onto the people expected to maintain the housing.
The danger is not that every building will suddenly be seized. The danger is the steady normalization of a more troubling idea: that private property is yours to manage only until government decides another buyer better serves its political goals. Once that principle takes hold, ownership becomes less secure and investment becomes harder to justify.
The city’s housing crisis is real. So is the cost of policies that discourage people from building, buying, repairing and renting homes. If COPA slows sales, scares off investment or leaves buildings in limbo, tenants will pay the price along with owners. Fewer willing buyers and less capital do not create more housing. They create a smaller, older and more fragile housing market.
Mamdani and the Council have made their choice. They have given favored organizations a special place in the purchase process and told owners that selling covered buildings now comes with a government-designed obstacle course. New Yorkers should demand answers: Who qualifies? How will these organizations be held accountable? What happens when a purchase fails or a building deteriorates? And who pays when the promised preservation does not materialize?
Private owners are not an inconvenience to be managed out of the housing market. They are part of the system that keeps buildings operating and homes available. COPA may be sold as a safeguard, but it marks a dangerous expansion of government power over private property. If City Hall wants to preserve housing, it should make it easier to maintain and build homes—not make ownership feel like a privilege the government can ration.