A judge’s authority is essential to the justice system. But authority without restraint can turn a courtroom into a place where the people seeking justice are made to feel powerless.
Two recent cases show what judicial misconduct can look like—and how differently it can be punished.
In Los Angeles, Judge Robert S. Draper was ordered removed from office after California’s Commission on Judicial Performance found 17 acts of misconduct. The findings included inappropriate racial comments, conduct reflecting gender bias, improper communications, and a failure to cooperate with the investigation. The commission also said Draper showed little remorse and failed to accept responsibility. The removal order is subject to discretionary review by the California Supreme Court.
In Texas, Harris County Judge Nathan Milliron received a public warning after the State Commission on Judicial Conduct found repeated failures to treat people with patience, dignity, and courtesy. The findings covered his viral rebuke of an IT worker, insulting messages about a clerk’s office supervisor, ordering an attorney to appear after criticizing his behavior, and threatening to have another attorney handcuffed. The commission also found that Milliron denied attorneys and their client an opportunity to be heard.
The outcomes are not the same: Draper was ordered removed; Milliron was publicly warned. The cases involve different records and different findings. But both raise the same question: What does judicial authority mean if the person holding it treats others as though their dignity and right to be heard are optional?
A judge may maintain order. A judge may make difficult rulings. But the robe does not excuse contempt, intimidation, or disregard for the people who come before the court. The law depends on judges applying its standards to others—and accepting that those standards apply to them, too.
And for those of us who have long sought answers about U.S. District Court Judge Victor Bolden, in Connecticut, one can only hope he has his day coming: a day when the concerns raised about his conduct receive a fair, transparent, and definitive accounting. Accountability should never depend on a judge’s title or position.