A Slogan Is Not a Policy

Posted byEd KowalskiPosted inUncategorized

When Pat Ryan stood before a Hudson Valley crowd and declared, “Do not mess with the Hudson Valley,” it made for a strong headline.

It stirred emotion.

It drew applause.

It framed him as a defender of the region.

But slogans are not policies.

The controversy centers around a proposed ICE processing facility in Chester. Ryan has been unequivocal in his opposition, calling such facilities un-American and pledging to fight their placement here. He has also rejected campaign contributions connected to ICE contractors and aligned himself with immigrant advocacy groups.

That’s clear.

What is not clear is this:

What does he propose instead for criminal illegal aliens?

Not for families seeking asylum.

Not for visa overstays with no criminal history.

But for individuals here unlawfully who have committed serious crimes.

The public record shows strong opposition to detention expansion. It shows passionate language about due process and humane treatment. It shows political resistance to federal infrastructure in the Valley.

What it does not show is a clearly articulated enforcement alternative.

Should criminal illegal aliens be detained?

If so, where?

If not locally, then where?

Should they be deported after conviction?

What crimes qualify?

What reforms does he support in statute?

These are not fringe questions. They are central to public safety.

The Hudson Valley is compassionate — but it is also practical. Veterans in Castle Point deserve safety. Families in Chester deserve transparency. Small business owners deserve clarity. When an elected official draws a line in the sand, voters deserve to know what lies behind it.

Opposing a facility is a position.

Proposing a solution is leadership.

Immigration enforcement is not binary. One can oppose abusive detention practices while still supporting the removal of violent offenders. One can demand due process while acknowledging that criminal activity forfeits certain privileges.

The Valley is not naïve. We understand complexity.

If the message is “Don’t mess with the Hudson Valley,” then the follow-up must be:

Here is how we protect it.

Because without a concrete proposal for handling criminal illegal aliens, the statement risks becoming political theater rather than public policy.

And here in the Hudson Valley, we expect more than theater.

Published by Ed Kowalski

Ed Kowalski is a Pleasant Valley resident, media voice, and policy-focused professional whose work sits at the intersection of law, public policy, and community life. Ed has spent his career working in senior leadership roles across human resources, compliance, and operations, helping organizations navigate complex legal and regulatory environments. His work has focused on accountability, risk management, workforce issues, and translating policy and law into practical outcomes that affect people’s jobs, livelihoods, and communities. Ed is also a familiar voice in the Hudson Valley media landscape. He most recently served as the morning host of Hudson Valley This Morning on WKIP and is currently a frequent contributor to Hudson Valley Focus with Tom Sipos on Pamal Broadcasting. In addition, Ed is the creator of The Valley Viewpoint, a commentary and narrative platform focused on law, justice, government accountability, and the real-world impact of public policy. Across broadcast and written media, Ed’s work emphasizes transparency, access to justice, institutional integrity, and public trust. Ed is a graduate of Xavier High School, Fordham University, and Georgetown University, holding a Certificate in Business Leadership from Georgetown. His Jesuit education shaped his belief that ideas carry obligations—and that leadership requires both discipline and moral clarity. He lives in Pleasant Valley.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.