When Democracy Becomes Optional

A Valley Viewpoint Narrative

You can learn a lot about the future of a community by watching who shows up to vote when nobody’s looking.

Here in the Hudson Valley, we pride ourselves on being plugged-in — engaged, opinionated, committed to our towns, our schools, and our sense of place. But the numbers tell a different story, especially among the youngest voters.

In the big, emotional national elections — the kind with wall-to-wall cable coverage and stadium rallies — voters in our region turn out at healthy levels. Roughly 64% of eligible adults in the Hudson Valley cast ballots in 2020. That’s the Valley doing its duty.

But then the cameras leave, the hashtags fade, and democracy goes quiet. And when that happens, turnout drops like a stone — down to 47% in 2022. That’s not a swing — that’s a collapse.

And if you zoom in on younger voters, the picture gets even dimmer. Statewide studies show the registration rate for 18-year-olds lags far behind the pace at which young people become eligible to vote. That’s not apathy — that’s the quiet beginning of civic absenteeism. The belief that participation is optional. That someone else will handle the decisions that shape their world.

The irony? When you ask young people whether they would learn about voting in a dedicated class, 40% say yes. The curiosity is there. The interest is there. But turning that interest into action — turning civic awareness into civic habit — that’s where the wheels fall off.

And this isn’t some abstract philosophical problem.

In school board elections across the region, turnout often scrapes single digits. Five to ten percent of eligible voters picking the people who decide school budgets, curriculum direction, infrastructure, and long-term investment in the next generation. The very group that stands to inherit the consequences — the students — largely doesn’t show up. Or can’t. Or doesn’t think it matters.

This is how a democracy frays — not with mobs in the streets, but with quiet shrugs. With “I don’t know enough.” With “it’s just local.” With the belief that real politics only happens in Washington.

But here in the Valley, we know better.

We know the most tangible power — the kind that fills potholes, funds schools, polices streets, and shapes neighborhoods — lives right here at home. In board meetings and town halls. On county ballots and school district lines.

The danger isn’t that young people disagree with us.
The danger is they don’t show up at all.

Because when the future stops voting, the future stops belonging to them.

And sooner or later, they’ll wonder how decisions were made — who drew the map, who set the taxes, who chose the priorities. And the answer will be simple:

Whoever bothered to show up.

That’s the quiet lesson here in the Valley. Democracy doesn’t die loudly. It fades quietly — not from anger, but from indifference.

And indifference, unlike ideology, never builds anything.

It just leaves the field open for whoever still thinks it’s worth playing.

Published by Ed Kowalski

You just have to do what you know is right.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.